top of page

PROJECT: WHY SSS CONTINUES TO RAISE THE ISSUE OF FOOT-AND- MOUTH DISEASE (PART 7)

7h
7 min read

PLEASE SHARE THIS PUBLIC DOCUMENT

GOVERNMENT ACCOUNTABILITY, CRIMINAL NEGLIGENCE

AND THE FAILURE TO PROTECT SOUTH AFRICA'S AGRICULTURAL INTERESTS


Specialised Security Services (SSS) continues to highlight South Africa's Foot-and-Mouth Disease (FMD) crisis

because the consequences extend far beyond an animal-health emergency.


This has become a national issue involving agricultural security, food production, economic stability,

rural livelihoods, public administration and the protection of national resources.

Since the beginning of its Project Foot-and-Mouth Disease series, SSS has repeatedly raised concerns

about inadequate disease-control measures, insufficient veterinary capacity, vaccine availability,

uncontrolled livestock movements, weak enforcement and the financial consequences for farming communities.


These concerns have not disappeared. The continued spread of the disease, together with its reported emergence

in wildlife populations, makes sustained public scrutiny increasingly important.

SSS is not raising this matter to create political controversy. Its purpose is to identify potential failures,

highlight criminal opportunities, protect vulnerable communities and demand accountability

from those entrusted with public responsibilities.


A national crisis cannot be managed through public announcements and promises alone.

It requires measurable action, competent administration, effective enforcement and accountability.

1. GOVERNMENT RESPONSIBILITY IS A LEGAL OBLIGATION:

  • South Africa's Constitution establishes clear principles for public administration.

  • Section 195 requires public administration to be accountable, transparent, ethical and efficient. Section 237 requires constitutional obligations to be performed diligently and without delay.

  • The Animal Diseases Act 35 of 1984 provides the legislative framework for controlling animal diseases, including FMD. Government veterinary authorities have responsibilities relating to disease surveillance, control and the implementation of applicable measures.

  • SSS's previous publications have questioned whether these responsibilities have been fulfilled adequately and timeously.


THE PUBLIC HAS A LEGITIMATE RIGHT TO ASK:

  • Why did the disease continue spreading despite repeated warnings?

  • Why were vaccine availability and veterinary capacity not addressed more effectively?

  • Why have livestock movement controls remained a significant concern?

  • Why have illegal grazing and uncontrolled animal movements created continuing biosecurity risks?

  • Were public funds allocated and spent effectively?

  • Who was responsible for implementing the announced interventions?

  • What consequences followed where officials failed to fulfil their responsibilities?


  • Government accountability is not optional. However, it is important to distinguish political failure, administrative misconduct and criminal conduct. Not every government failure constitutes a criminal offence, but evidence of unlawful conduct must be investigated.

2. WHEN GOVERNMENT FAILURE BECOMES A CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION:

The failure to take accountability is not, by itself, a separate criminal offence. However, where identifiable officials breach legally imposed duties, act dishonestly, abuse their authority or culpably fail to perform responsibilities, criminal liability may arise if the elements of a recognised offence are established.


The following areas warrant particular scrutiny:

  • CORRUPTION – PRECCA 12 OF 2004:

    • Investigators should examine possible bribery, conflicts of interest, improper procurement arrangements and the acceptance of gratification in exchange for facilitating unlawful livestock movements or manipulating vaccine contracts.

  • FRAUD AND PROCUREMENT FRAUD:

    • Possible offences include false supplier documentation, inflated invoices, fraudulent claims for services not delivered, falsified procurement records and dishonest representations concerning vaccine supplies.

  • THEFT AND MISAPPROPRIATION OF PUBLIC RESOURCES:

    • Any unlawful diversion of vaccines, equipment or public funds allocated for disease control must be investigated.

  • FINANCIAL MISCONDUCT – PFMA 1 OF 1999:

    • The Public Finance Management Act establishes duties relating to public financial management. Unauthorised, irregular, fruitless and wasteful expenditure must be properly identified and addressed. Specified wilful or grossly negligent failures can also constitute criminal offences under section 86.

  • CONTRAVENTIONS OF THE ANIMAL DISEASES ACT:

    • The unlawful movement of livestock, failure to comply with applicable movement restrictions, failure to report suspected controlled disease where legally required, and the falsification of veterinary documentation may result in criminal or regulatory consequences.

  • ANIMAL CRUELTY – ANIMALS PROTECTION ACT 71 OF 1962:

    • Where animals are deliberately or unlawfully neglected, denied necessary care or subjected to preventable suffering, an animal-cruelty investigation may be justified. An outbreak itself, or a farmer's inability to obtain veterinary assistance, does not automatically constitute cruelty.

  • CRIMINAL NEGLIGENCE AND UNLAWFUL OMISSIONS:

    • Where an identifiable official has a legally recognised duty to act, fails to fulfil that duty and the required elements of a criminal offence are established, an omission may attract criminal liability.

    • Where a negligent unlawful omission causes a person's death, culpable homicide may be considered if its legal requirements are met. This cannot be assumed merely because government action was inadequate.


3. THE CRIMINAL OPPORTUNITIES CREATED BY WEAK ENFORCEMENT:

  • Weak disease-control systems create opportunities for criminal activity.

  • The following risks require attention:

    • Stock theft and the movement of stolen livestock into unauthorised markets.

    • Illegal transportation of livestock across provincial boundaries.

    • Bribery to bypass roadblocks, inspections and movement restrictions.

    • Fraudulent veterinary certificates and livestock permits.

    • Theft or diversion of vaccines and agricultural resources.

    • Fraudulent procurement and manipulation of government contracts.

    • Fake agricultural relief programmes targeting financially distressed farmers.

    • Identity theft and fraudulent funding applications.

    • Extortion involving promises of permits, veterinary assistance or access to restricted markets.

  • SSS believes that the FMD crisis must therefore also be examined from an economic-crime and rural-security perspective.


4. THE FINANCIAL CONSEQUENCES FOR FARMERS AND RURAL COMMUNITIES:

  • Farmers have been placed under considerable financial pressure through livestock movement restrictions, cancelled auctions, reduced trading opportunities and uncertainty about the duration of the outbreak.

  • Their operational costs do not stop when livestock sales are restricted. They must continue paying employees, maintaining infrastructure, feeding animals, servicing debt and meeting other financial commitments.

  • The consequences extend to transport operators, feed suppliers, veterinarians, agricultural contractors, meat processors and rural businesses.

  • In its previous Part 5 publication, SSS specifically addressed this situation and encouraged farmers experiencing financial difficulties to seek early assistance from qualified business-rescue professionals.

  • Business rescue is a legal mechanism that may help viable farming operations stabilise and negotiate with creditors. It is not a substitute for disease control, but it may provide an important option for businesses facing financial distress.

  • SSS also reiterates that it does not provide financial advice or act as a licensed financial services provider.

5. WHAT MUST BE INVESTIGATED?

SSS believes that the management of the FMD crisis warrants transparent scrutiny and, where evidence justifies it, independent investigation.


The investigation should establish:

  1. Whether government commitments were translated into measurable operational results.

  2. Whether vaccine procurement and distribution were lawful, transparent and effective.

  3. Whether public expenditure was properly authorised and accounted for.

  4. Whether veterinary capacity and disease surveillance were adequately supported.

  5. Whether illegal livestock movements and breaches of quarantine requirements were investigated.

  6. Whether corruption, fraud or diversion of public resources occurred.

  7. Whether officials who failed to fulfil specific statutory duties were held accountable.

  8. Whether criminal referrals, disciplinary proceedings and financial recovery measures were initiated where warranted.

The investigation must identify individual responsibilities and rely on documentary evidence, procurement records, financial audits, operational reports and properly obtained witness statements.


PUBLIC ACCOUNTABILITY MUST HAVE CONSEQUENCES


SSS will continue raising the FMD issue because the consequences are ongoing and the public deserves answers.

Farmers should not be left to carry the full financial burden of a national disease-control crisis while questions concerning government performance, procurement, enforcement and expenditure remain unanswered.


Public officials must be held accountable for their decisions and omissions.

Where evidence indicates criminal conduct, the appropriate authorities must investigate

and prosecute where the evidence and law justify it.

Political promises are not operational results. Announcements are not enforcement.

Allocated budgets are not proof of effective delivery.

When public responsibilities are neglected, questions must be asked.

When laws are broken, investigations must follow.

When criminal conduct is established, those responsible must face the consequences.


SSS will continue monitoring, investigating and informing the public because South Africa's agricultural economy,

food security and rural communities cannot afford for this matter to disappear from public attention.

Understanding the accountability issues surrounding this project provides the necessary context for Part 8,

which examines the additional threat posed by the spread of foot-and-mouth disease into South Africa's

wildlife populations and the resulting implications for conservation.

RELEVANT SSS PROJECTS:

Specialised Security Services invites the public to the Mike Bolhuis Daily Projects WhatsApp Channel.

This channel is important in delivering insights into the latest crime trends, awareness, warnings and the exposure of criminals.


How to Join the WhatsApp Channel:

1. Make sure you have the latest version of WhatsApp on your device.

2. Click on the link below to join the Mike Bolhuis Daily Projects WhatsApp Channel:

3. Follow the prompts to join the channel.

4. Make sure you click on "Follow", then click on the "bell"-icon (🔔)

CONTACT MR MIKE BOLHUIS FOR SAFETY AND SECURITY MEASURES, PROTECTION, OR AN INVESTIGATION IF NEEDED.

ALL INFORMATION RECEIVED WILL BE TREATED IN THE STRICTEST CONFIDENTIALITY AND EVERY IDENTITY WILL BE PROTECTED.

Regards,

Mike Bolhuis

Specialist Investigators into

Serious Violent, Serious Economic Crimes & Serious Cybercrimes

PSIRA Reg. 1590364/421949

Mobile: +27 82 447 6116

Fax: 086 585 4924

Follow us on Facebook to view our projects -


EXTREMELY IMPORTANT: All potential clients need to be aware that owing to the nature of our work as specialist investigators there are people who have been caught on the wrong side of the law - who are trying to discredit me - Mike Bolhuis and my organisation Specialised Security Services - to get themselves off the hook. This retaliation happens on social media and creates doubt about our integrity and ability. Doubt created on social media platforms is both unwarranted and untrue. We strongly recommend that you make up your minds concerning me and our organisation only after considering all the factual information - to the exclusion of hearsay and assumptions. Furthermore, you are welcome to address your concerns directly with me should you still be unsatisfied with your conclusions. While the internet provides a lot of valuable information, it is also a platform that distributes a lot of false information. The distribution of false information, fake news, slander and hate speech constitutes a crime that can be prosecuted by law. Your own research discretion and discernment are imperative when choosing what and what not to believe.


STANDARD RULES APPLY: Upon appointment, we require a formal mandate with detailed instructions. Please take note that should you not make use of our services – you may not under any circumstance use my name or the name of my organisation as a means to achieve whatever end.


POPI ACT 4 of 2013 South Africa: Mike Bolhuis' "Specialised Security Services" falls under Section 6 of the act. Read more here: https://mikebh.link/fntdpv

SSS TASK TEAM:

Copyright © 2015- PRESENT | Mike Bolhuis Specialised Security Services | All rights reserved.


Our mailing address is:

Mike Bolhuis Specialised Security Services

PO Box 15075 Lynn East

Pretoria, Gauteng 0039

South Africa

Add us to your address book


THIS PUBLIC DOCUMENT WAS INTENDED TO BE SHARED, PLEASE DO SO.

CONTACT US

Pretoria, 75 Wapad, Leeuwfontein Estate, Roodeplaat, 0186, South Africa

​​

E-mail: mike@mikebolhuis.co.za
Mobile: 082 447  6116
International: +27 82
447 6116
Fax: 086 585 4924

  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • YouTube
  • TikTok
chat with mike bolhuis on whatsapp

Thanks for submitting!

Copyright © mikebolhuis.co.za

MLB DIENSTE CC Reg: 1995/036819/23

PSIRA Reg: 1590364/421949

Web design by Mike Bolhuis Cybercrime Unit

bottom of page